My favorite part of listening to a new Yo La Tengo album for the first time is anticipating what their obligatory 10-minute song is going to be like. With Painful being the only exception, all of their other full-lengths since James McNew came aboard have had at least one (note: I’m aware that some songs, like “Blue Line Swingers” fall a little short of the 10-minute mark – that’s close enough for me, bucko). May I Sing With Me and I Am Not Afraid Of You And I Will Beat Your Ass have two of them. There newest album, Popular Songs, goes all out and gives us three monster tracks at the end.
I’ve yet to hear those three monster tracks (my trip to the record store is later today). If it were any other band, backloading an album in this way would make me a bit weary. But this is Yo La Tengo, and no one does the 10-minute song better.
Here are my 5 favorites, taken from both their albums and their multitude of EP’s:
1) Blue Line Swinger (Electr-O-Pura)

Probably my favorite song ever. Their are sentimental reasons for this, of course. Electr-O-Pura was the first YLT album I bought, purloined from the five dollar clearance section at the Sound Exchange in Tampa. Back then, I would buy any CD if it was cheap and the album cover looked interesting, so I had no idea what to expect when the 18-year old version of myself put the CD into the stereo. After the first couple songs, I realized that I had stumbled upon a damn good band. By the time “Blue Line Swinger” was over, Yo La Tengo had become my favorite band.
2) Night Falls On Hoboken (And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside-Out)

Beautiful. The quietest moment in their most subdued album. That bass groove . . . man, I can listen to that for hours. Because I’m weird, I actually consider this song to be a great one to listen to while driving late at night. For anyone else, it would put them to sleep.
3) Mr Ameche Plays The Stranger (Camp Yo La Tengo EP, also Prisoners Of Love Bonus Disc)

Another mellow one, but with a much different vibe than “Night Falls On Hoboken”. The two weird samples – a guy repeating ‘Mr Ameche plays the stranger’ and a little girl asking for candy and potato chips (?) – sell it for me, adding a bit of creepiness to the listening experience. Here, see for yourself:
Yo La Tengo – Mr. Ameche Plays The Stranger
4) Spec Bebob (I Can Hear The Heart Beating As One)

Sequenced oddly between a bossa nova number (the lovely “Center Of Gravity”) and the end-of-album showstopper (“We’re An American Band”), this is an 11-minute exercise in noisy skronk that has no business being on this album. But somehow it works. Again, with any other band this would ruin the album. But Yo La Tengo – those charming buggers – manage to pull it off.
5) Sunsquashed (Upside Down EP; alternate version also available on Genius + Love = Yo La Tengo)

Many moons ago, I was a manager at a record store, mainly working the evening shift. As with any retail job, when closing time crept closer, I wanted to get out of there as quickly as possible. This meant we had to get rid of the customers, in particular the ones who would keep hanging around even after repeated announcements that the store would be closing very shortly.
To help us with this, the other managers and I had amassed a small collection of music designed to drive customers away. One manager went with a yodeling CD. Another manager would pick a compilation of Tuvan throat singing (if you’ve never heard this, go here right now).
I went with “Sunsquashed”. It’s got a sound similar to a broken amp that squalls throughout the entire song. For 24 minutes (and the alternate version is longer!).
Worked like a charm.
If you’ve got a different set of favorites amongst Yo La Tengo’s canon of super-long songs, I’d love to know. Leave your comments below, yo.